Home › Forums › NOE Forums › NOE Archive › Historical Archive › Group Buys › Group Buy Discussions › RCBS-Hodgdon in .578
- This topic is empty.
-
CreatorTopic
-
2015-07-10 at 15:51 #488169
maillemaker
::Hi all,
I just discovered this mold maker / forum.
I love that they can make hollow-base multi-cavity molds.
One of the more tedious aspects of muzzle loader shooting is the single-cavity molds I have had to deal with for minie balls.
I would love to see the “N-SSA Skirmisher” bullet, the RCBS-Hodgdon, made in .578 in an RG2 and RG4 style.
Lots of skirmishers shoot this bullet in competition.
Thanks,
Steve
-
CreatorTopic
-
AuthorReplies
-
2015-08-20 at 15:39 #4992322015-08-22 at 11:59 #499233
adamsutherland
Moderator::Out off curiosity I bought a few of these sizers from SSfirearms and they arrived today.
They seem OK, the lube holes in the die body are drilled very close together so that it is almost one long hole.
Looks like they will only work in the old Lyman 45 sizers as the hole in the bottom of the lubesizer casing isn’t big enough to allow the “I” part (ejector pin) of the die to go through.
Currently cooking out the 50/50 lube from one of my 45s to replace with BP to give it a try.
2015-08-22 at 13:29 #499234adamsutherland
Moderator::OK I swapped the lubes over in my Lyman 45 and put it back on the bench dropped in an SSfirearms 0.576″ and started running some RCBS Minies through it.
Not impressed I have to say, the wall is so thing where the retaining screw groove is that the retaining screw tension is critical too much and the die body pinches letting the lube spew forth and you can feel the tightness on the “I” pin. The lube slots come far too far down on the body so when ejecting the Minie the lube leaks out of the bottom of the pin.
They can be made to work watch the retaining screw tension, block up the bottom part of the lube holes/slot with lead shot to stop the lube leakage or back off the pressure when ejecting the bullet, all in all a real faff on so a shame really but I did suspect that such thin meat on the die walls would be a problem.
2015-08-31 at 20:24 #499235maillemaker
::I’m using the LYMAN LUBER-SIZER #450/4500, which I bought from S&S as advertised to work with their sizing dies.
I’m afraid I don’t follow much of your terminology. I don’t know what the “retaining screw” is that you are speaking of nor the “I” pin. My Lubrizier has a threaded nut that holds the sizing die in place. I only thread it down lightly with the wrench included with the Lubrisier.
I find you have to adjust the stop screw/shaft correctly for the kind of bullet you are lubing so that on the down stroke the bullet stops at the correct location. If the bullet goes too deep then it passes the lube holes and lube will squirt onto the nose of the bullet.
I do tend to get lube leakage out the bottom of the bullet sizer.
But all in all, I find it very convenient, sizing and lubing the minies in one go.
How do you usually go about sizing and lubing your minies?
Steve
2015-08-31 at 23:56 #499236maillemaker
::Here’s a quick video of me sizing and lubing an RCBS-Hodgdon to .576.
Steve
2015-09-01 at 05:39 #499237adamsutherland
Moderator::Thanks I know how to use the Lubesizers. I run 2 Lyman 45s, 2 Lyman 450s and 3 RCBS LAMs 1&2s along with the Vickers
There is still a lot of leakage and messiness in your video even with the different press.
That is the latest Lyman 4500 you are using, got rid of mine due to ram alignment issues, maybe they have a larger hole in the press body for the “I” pin to pass through, see reply 12 for nomenclature, or they are enlarging them for the larger size dies. Didn’t notice anywhere on the S&S site that these dies would only work with specific lubesizers.
I rarely size preferring to cast to size with these bullets and then just dip lube.
When I need to I use a one off lubesizer made at Vickers Armstrong many decades ago specifically for sizing these larger bullets, however as it takes a larger H&I die then I need to have these custom made. Would have been good if the S&S dies had worked as that would have cut down the waiting times for custom dies.
Here are some photographs of the Vickers Armstrong lube sizer I use.





I can still use the S&S dies in the Perfessor’s push through doofur that I have but they will still need dip lubing, thus not gaining the convenience of a lubsizer.
I had hoped against reason that they would work but as I suspected the metal is just too thin on the die body with these large diameters.
Thank you for your contribution anyway.
2015-09-01 at 20:42 #499238maillemaker
::Didn’t notice anywhere on the S&S site that these dies would only work with specific lubesizers.
The link for their Lyman Lubrisizer:
http://ssfirearms.com/proddetail.asp?prod=SA173
Says: “LYMAN LUBER-SIZER #450/4500, FOR USE WITH OUR SIZING DIES“
The link for the dies:
http://ssfirearms.com/proddetail.asp?prod=SA450
Says: “PRECISION MACHINED FOR USE WITH LYMAN #450/4500 LUBER-SIZER, LISTED ELSEWHERE IN CATALOG. COMPLETE WITH TOP BULLET PUNCH. ORDER SIZE REQUIRED. FROM .250 THRU .600 IN .001 INCREMENTS”
So I would gather from that that they made these dies to work with the Lyman #450/4500 that they sell. Maybe they will work in other presses, I don’t know.
I rarely size preferring to cast to size with these bullets and then just dip lube.
Sometimes you get lucky and your mold will drop at precisely the required diameter, but most precision shooters I know in my game (N-SSA) size their bullets to match their barrels. The ideal seems to be .001″-.002″ undersize of the bore. I find that even when I get a bullet that fits snugly as-cast I will size them to make them perfectly round. Plus I find it is easier to lube them in the sizer than to dip lube them.
There is still a lot of leakage and messiness in your video even with the different press.
You have to set the stop correctly as if the bullet goes too deep into the sizer the shoulder will go below the lube ports and lube will then of course squirt up onto the nose of the bullet. Once that is done I find that firm pressure on the bullet ram once the bullet has bottomed out generally keep lube from creeping under the bullet into the hollow cavity, but that does happen over time – I just squeegy off the excess as needed.
The setup does leak lube out the bottom of the press.
But also, I’m running a very runny lube. My lube is just slightly thicker than the consistency of petroleum jelly.
I’m going to size for precision anyway, so if I can lube at the same time that works for me. I dip-lube Wilkinson bullets because you can’t lube them in a lubrisizer (it would pack the compression groove with lube) and I find that is a lot more mess and time consuming than lubing in the sizer. Now if I had to do a lot of dip lubing I might build myself a big pan/fixture where I could dip dozens at a time like a fry basket at McDonald’s but right now I’m dipping my Wilkinsons individually in an old cap tin sitting on a hot plate. I’d prefer mechanical lubing to that any day.
I had hoped against reason that they would work but as I suspected the metal is just too thin on the die body with these large diameters.
I’m not seeing the effect of the groove on anything. But then, I don’t know what the purpose of the groove is, either. It looks like an O-ring groove, and I see your dies have o-rings, but my dies from S&S did not come with o-rings so I do not have any o-rings on my dies.
In any case, as you can see from the video sizing and lubing is quick and easy for me. I’ve never used any other sizer so maybe it’s terrible compared to others, I don’t know. I didn’t even know there were other lubrisizers available for .58 caliber bullets.
Steve
2015-09-02 at 07:23 #499239adamsutherland
Moderator::I would suggest that you plug up the bottom lube holes in the die body with lead shot sufficient only to allow the the lubing of the bullet when fully seated in the press, that will help stem the spewing of lube from the bottom of the press. On my dies from S&S the holes are drilled so close together that it is almost one continuous hole hopefully yours are better made. You also seem to be getting a lot of leakage under the bullet base onto the ejector pin a slightly over size disc of plastic foam from a catering box will also help stop this.
I also use a soft lube like that made from tallow/beeswax and Lanacote but it does not need to be messy if you are using decent lube/sizing dies.
As you say sizing and lubing in one step is faster than sizing and dipping in two steps however when the lube sizing is so messy then the clean up time detracts from the theory of that.
For most of my Minies I have moulds that drop to specification so sizing is not necessary so the only process needed is lubing, dip lubing is load quicker than using a lube sizer. The other thing about sizing minies is that the lube/scraping grooves on most designs is very shallow so sizing is limited to a thou or so before the groove becomes redundant.
That is one of the good points about the Hodgdon design it has deeper grease grooves so will stand more sizing.
I am currently shooting three Parker Hales P53, P58 and a P61 along with an original W Bales P56 and the all have bore diameters spot on .577″ so sizing for each rifle is not necessary a .576″/.575″ bullet does the job nicely on them all.
2015-09-03 at 18:49 #499240maillemaker
::You also seem to be getting a lot of leakage under the bullet base onto the ejector pin a slightly over size disc of plastic foam from a catering box will also help stop this.
This is a good idea. I will look into some self-adhesive foam that I could stick to the face of the ejector. It will have to be something tough enough to not get chewed up by repeated crushing by the bullet though. Something sort of dense.
2015-09-03 at 18:50 #499241maillemaker
2015-09-04 at 06:41 #499242adamsutherland
Moderator::You also seem to be getting a lot of leakage under the bullet base onto the ejector pin a slightly over size disc of plastic foam from a catering box will also help stop this.
This is a good idea. I will look into some self-adhesive foam that I could stick to the face of the ejector. It will have to be something tough enough to not get chewed up by repeated crushing by the bullet though. Something sort of dense.
You don’t need to over think it, foam from a catering pack works just fine for over 100 bullets and then just replace it I use a wad punch to cut them out. No need for sticky backed as the lube on the ejector pin holds it in place just fine, KISS.
2015-09-04 at 06:53 #499243adamsutherland
Moderator::I am currently shooting three Parker Hales P53, P58 and a P61 along with an original W Bales P56 and the all have bore diameters spot on .577″ so sizing for each rifle is not necessary a .576″/.575″ bullet does the job nicely on them all.
What kind of groups do you get?
Steve
From the bench rested, weighed bullets, weighed charges and consistently wiping between shots I can get repeatable 5 shot 5″ centre to centre groups at 100 yards. The gun will probably do better but that is the best I can do with the open sights and my ageing eyes.
2015-09-05 at 08:42 #499244adamsutherland
Moderator2015-09-06 at 06:41 #499245adamsutherland
Moderator::A couple more thoughts.
450/4500 are two different seizers, the 45 is an early version and no longer made but are my personal favourite lubesizers, the S&S dies do work in this but the H&I die retention is different from the 4500 instead of a retaining nut on the top of the press there is a grub screw that goes through the press body into the retaining groove in the H&I die.
The Lyman 450 is the version before the latest 4500, it is also a good press and uses the retaining nut to secure the H7I die, the two of these I have will not take the S&S large H7I dies without grinding the bottom of the H&I die cavity.
The 4500 is Lymans latest rendition of a lube sizer and I have had a few through my hands and they have all had ram alignment issues but they could very well take the S&S dies.
Sizing for roundness isn’t necessary, if you bullets are than much out of round then you need to look to your mould and or casting technique. Considering the Minie style bullet is designed to expand to fill the barrel then any slight out of roundness is not an issue.
Regarding the drawing, why is there a rebated/heeled base? What is the purpose of this?
I would prefer a flat base to keep the lube separate from the powder, be less messy in a lubesizer and help castability.
2015-09-08 at 18:16 #499246 -
AuthorReplies
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.